Although short, this book gives a very interesting discussion of the history of the tension between the Islamic religion and the thrust towards modernization in the West. Belief systems are slow to adapt to new ideas, and this is brought out with great clarity in this book. Via the study of its past, the author gives the reader much insight into the events of today's Middle East, and inspires further reading on the subject.
The author discusses the need for the citizens of the Ottoman empire to emulate the technology of Western Europe. The underlying theme of the book is that European power, resulting from innovation and experiment, changed the balance of power between the Ottoman empire and Europe. But for a Muslim, living in Europe was an abomination. One should not mix with the infidels. The author explains the need though for Muslims to do just this, due to the threats from the West.
[The disciples of hate in 911 clearly did not mind living in Western society and learning of Western devices. One can only wonder if at any moment they may have connected with some of the people in the area in which they were living and then perhaps had second thoughts about what they were going to do. Anger and hate are emotions that are hard to sustain for long periods of time. They require much concentration to preserve. But a little religion always helps in this regard].
The Ottoman's solution to the threat of the West, was, according to the author, to return to the basics of the Islamic religion, a belief he reminds the reader is still predominant in the Middle East. What is most interesting from the standpoint of today is the role of France as being the dominant European influence. In the book the rise of the modern Middle East begins with the invasion of Egypt by Napoleon in 1798. Even before that time French schools existed in the Middle East and the French language was compulsory for military students.
One inevitably compares the three major religions of the West when reading the book. Interestingly, Islam "wins" if judged by tolerance for those of different beliefs and equal rights, but fails miserably when notice is made of the attitudes towards slaves and women. But as the author points out, a slave can become free by choice of his master. The status of woman in Islamic society though is static and immutable, unfortunately.
Clearly Middle Easteners were perplexed by the rise of the West and its achievements. What accounted for the superiority of the West? What is the source of Western success? Clearly, as the book brings out, Middle Easteners were seeking answers beyond that which religion gave them, and, in retrospect, they were certainly correct to doubt the efficacy of religion in this regard. For, as the author notes, it was the infidels who benefited from the changes taking place.
The author also addresses the role of technology in the modern Middle East in bringing about change, imposing limits on both rulers and teachers. But the cowards of 911 used technology in an attempt to bring about the demise of the West. However they could not use it without meeting their own demise, and have thus proven again the sterility of their belief system, and those that supported them.
Another interesting commentary in the book is the role of young people, particularly in Iran. Educated in the West, they brought to Iran the then alien ideas of freedom. With the turmoil now facing the leaders of Iran this very day, this is a special irony. Should one call the young people now battling in the streets of Iran the "New Young Ottomans", in reference to the "Young Ottomans" described in this book? The comparison might be too loose, since the street fighters now were not educated in the West (but they do have access to a huge information base of "corrupting" influences: the Internet).
The biggest tragedy in the history of Middle East is the reluctance of Islamic society to accept the science of the West, given the incredible contributions of the Middle East to modern science and mathematics. The author asks the reader to consider the question as to why one would accept Islam as being an obstacle to freedom, science, and economic development, when in the past, and at that time closer to the sources of Islamic faith than now, it was a pioneer in all three of these? The answer is quite straightforward from the standpoint of science: those that were introducing science were not acting like Muslims when they carried it out. Shall we call them Muslims who sometimes practiced science or scientists who sometimes acted like Muslims? Either designation will hold, for the two are diametrically opposed: no amount of prayer or supplication will bring about the results of science, for that is to be done with discipline of thought and painstaking experimentation...and no scientific experiment can illustrate the soundness of Islam, or indeed of any other religion, Western or otherwise.
In an afterword to the book, the author expresses grief and concern of course over the events of 911. He points out correctly that the followers of bin Laden are only a minority, and that most adherents of Islam are concerned with living in freedom, in living in a world that allows them to live their own lives under a responsible government. The author expresses hope that freedom will triumph as it did over the repressive regimes of the twentieth century.
But it will. The human mind of the twenty-first century is too efficacious to fail in its cause in this regard. And with billions of such minds populating our planet, the odds are against a grim future. Now more than ever is the time to be proud of being a member of the human species.
Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Discover the latest buzz-worthy books, from mysteries and romance to humor and nonfiction. Explore more
Frequently bought together
This item: What Went Wrong?: The Clash Between Islam and Modernity in the Middle East
$21.62
Get it as soon as Saturday, May 10
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
+
$6.66
Get it May 6 - 9
Only 1 left in stock - order soon.
Total price: $00
To see our price, add these items to your cart.
Choose items to buy together.
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Page 1 of 1 Start overPage 1 of 1
About the author
The book is not original
Printing is faulty. The book is not original, it might be an illegal copy.
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on May 17, 2014
Top reviews from other countries
-
EwgenijReviewed in Germany on January 18, 2016
Sehr interessant und Aufschlußreich!
- K. D. MachellReviewed in the United Kingdom on May 15, 2017
Not sure why it wasnt kept on the shelves because its a great book.
-
